 A question that I often hear brought up in therapy is when is it appropriate to cut off my family members? This has become a popular topic these days as generational differences, awareness of trauma, and politics divides family.
As systemic marriage and family therapists, we are trained to study family ancestral trees called genograms and look for patterns of connection, attachment, abuse, substance abuse, and cutoffs. Whenever cutoffs show up in a genogram, it tells us something important about the family dynamic and signs of dysfunction. Generally, we discourage folks from immediately considering cutoffs vs exploring alternate options. What are the alternatives to cutoffs Rather than black and white thinking, that things have to be "all this way" or "all that way" or we are a family unit or we have no connection, as family therapists we often encourage people to explore they gray areas. What about decreasing length of visits or frequency of contacts? Instead of going over every holiday, maybe only go to one, and don’t stay with them, limit your time there and stay at a hotel. Maybe instead of taking all their calls, you choose selectively when to respond or you just send them cards. There are many times as people explore their development and really individuate from their parents and begin to develop their own sense of identity and beliefs, that they suddenly see problems in their relationship with their family members that were not fully realized prior. Or perhaps the parent is struggling with adapting to the new role of having an independent, adult child where they have less control. At that point, as growing awareness blooms into anger and contempt, sometimes prompted by an outsiders’ view of your family such as partner, teacher, friend, or therapist that the drive to cut-off a family member or make big changes in boundaries with family comes about. When is a cutoff appropriate? Sometimes folks have decided that the only way they can have some peace is to cut off their family members. This is especially true when family members have displayed long patterns of egregious, toxic, abusive, manipulative, or selfish behavior and are unlikely or unwilling to change, nor take accountability for their actions.
These are all examples of family dynamics that are difficult, if not impossible to manage. Sometimes, for one’s own safety or sanity, there is no recourse but to put distance from the harmful family member. Note, a person is not put into these categories simply because you do not approve of them, or they are not who you want them to be or what you believe, they meet these criteria when they are actively inflicting harm on others through their behavior, the pattern is chronic, and there is a demonstrable unwillingness or inability to change. Consequences of cutoffs Sometimes I encounter clients who, at the advise of younger clinicians, have decided to cut-off their family members with formal letters, over more minor and typical family conflicts. Rather than attempting to work through the issue in family therapy, the family member unceremoniously receives a letter that that have been disowned or a list of their infractions and have been informed they are going no-contact. They problem with formally making these statements in a letter is 1) it gives the other person no opportunity to respond, clarify, ask questions, or make amends. And since many issues come down to problems with communication and understanding, this can only exacerbate the problem. 2) You cannot take back the harm inflicted by a formal pronunciation that you are cutting off a family member, thus creating or exacerbating a rejection wound. Although many people experience family cut-offs for a time, rarely are they permanent. Most people end up reunifying with their family members within a few years. This is true for even the abusive, toxic family members, or the religiously based cut-offs. Writing letters to harmful family members are very powerful tools in therapy for clarifying your hurt, exploring boundaries, and finding cathartic release. As a trauma counselor I have been witness to thousands of these letters over the years. However, a therapeutic exercise for the self is not the same thing as sending one of those letters to a family member and should be taken with great care and consideration. Sometimes folks who struggle with assertiveness or have fears/challenges with being communication/being heard by their family member may feel letter writing is the only option necessary, which may be true, but it’s also important to know that what is formally written may be hard to take back or make repairs from as well. There is also no guarantee they will read it. Cautions of cut offs If your attempt at a cut off is to get the person comply, to punish, to be more the way you want them to be, then you could be abusing the situation and using the cut-off as a tool for emotional manipulation. If, by contrast, you are using the cut-off as a tool for safety when all methods of communication, family therapy, consultation with faith leaders, and boundary setting have failed, this is totally appropriate. This is especially true when there are no signs of positive change or willingness to change or willingness to take responsibility for the harm that has been caused, and they are in-fact doubling down on their behavior and blaming you for it. Red flags. As a family therapist, I have witnessed the devastating impact of trauma and clients struggling to set limits with narcissistic parents who continue to ignore and cross boundaries. I have also seen the tragic result of when clients are unceremoniously cut-off by their family members and the pain, sadness, and confusion that results. Many times the person being cut-off genuinely does not recall the events they are being accused of and are shocked at the variation in perspectives. There is no easy path and the decisions you make today may impact generations to come. It's important to remember that small, consistent shifts in your behavior can change the larger family system functioning over time. A note for parents: Sometimes parents feel blamed a lot in the therapy process, and the fear of being blamed or judged can keep them away from participating in family therapy. This is a fair concern as parents do take a brunt of the impact when their is family dysfunction. It's important to remember that there are no perfect parents. And even the best parents are going to say or do something at some point that harms their child directly or indirectly. In family therapy we really stress the idea of a "good enough parent". In order for children to develop well, you just need a good enough parent. Most parents do many more good things than bad things. A bad choice does not automatically equate with a bad person/parent/child. Sometimes the positive contributions and the way the parent shows love is not readily recognized. For example, a child may say they did not feel love because dad did not hug them or say "I love you" or was overly strict or critical or said things that made them feel bad about themselves, but that same dad may have shown love through showing up all their sporting events, making sure to always have a job and steady income to support the family, by fixing things around the house to create a safe environment for them, by making sure they had a car to get to their job or college. How a person receives love may not be the same as how another expresses love. Parents do however have the responsibility, as the older person with more power and authority in the relational dynamics, of being the one to reach out to their children and initiate contact occasionally. It cannot be left just up to the child/adult child. The child also has a responsibility of returning the calls and checking back in occasionally as well if they both wish to maintain a relationship. Parents do have the burden of being the bigger person, because of child's need for unconditional love from the parent. If you are considering a cut-off, try these steps first
Author: Megan Garza, MA, LMFT is a licensed Marriage and Family Therapist and Supervisor at Healing Reflections Therapy
0 Comments
|
AuthorSMegan Garza, MA, LMFT is a certified Specialist in Treating Trauma at a Supervisory level and is Licensed as a Marriage and Family Therapist. She specializes in work with sexual abuse survivors. Archives
December 2025
Categories |
RSS Feed