When is it ok to seek Mental Health Support for a Family Member?

The level of social support is the number one predictor of outcomes after trauma. Having support from a loved one came be a critical step in the healing process. Many family members ache when they see their loved one's suffer and are desperate to help them find relief, and to find relief for themselves of the anxiety and distress the helpless creates.

Seeking mental health support from a family member has some pros and cons. In general, seeking out therapy can be helpful, however not everyone is ready to take that step for themself. This can become a point of distress as family members get desperate for change with ongoing worry. 

Here are some things that therapists want you to know when you reach out on their behalf.

1)Reaching out to therapists on behalf of someone else takes away their sense of agency/responsibility for their therapy process and can be a sign of patterns of enabling or codependence.
All too often  well meaning loved ones reach out on someone else's behalf for therapy, but more often than not those individuals have little motivation to participate in the process. When you make the call for them, it takes away their ownership of the issue. Well meaning family members can become enablers by allowing these individuals to not have to take the role of responsible adults. Women often complain that they get cast in the role of mother to their spouses, but they often enable the very problem they are frustrated with by continuing to make the calls for doctors visits and setting up the appointments for them.

2) Lack of motivation to reach out to a therapist is often predictive of one's motivation to participate in the treatment process.
Often therapists find that when someone else makes the arrangement for someone to attend therapy, the person making the call is more distressed and ready for change than the client is. As much as you want them to change, they may not be ready to. Part of the process of reaching otu to a therapist, filling out the intake forms, and coming to the first session is all part of someone's preparation for change. It involves accepting there is a problem, that you need help, and that you are willing to take steps to make change. When people are just "visiting" therapy and not ready to make change, they usually do not attend past the intake sessions, if they bother to show up for the intake at all. Prochaska & Diclemente (1983) developed the stages of change model that highlights the cycle and one's readiness to change, particularly as it applies to addiction, though this pattern is applicable to the overall therapy process.
​
3) Confidentiality is a barrier for us.
While you may want to advocate for them, your advocacy can only go so far when we are dealing with another adult who is their own guardian. Therapists are required to maintain confidentiality with their clients, so once they make contact, we cannot really communicate with you about them without a release. 

What about when your family member is too ill or depressed to advocate for themself or is a poor reporter/historian?

If someone is in a mental health crisis situation there a few options to consider. This situation is different than a situation where someone is enabling, but more occurs when the client is in such a poor state, they lack the capacity to take the steps for themself. For example, someone who is experiencing psychosis and cannot distinguish reality from a delusion, someone that is so depressed they are near catatonic and bed ridden, someone whose OCD has lead to a hazardous hoarding situation, or someone who is experiencing a manic episode and is engaging in high risk behavior, or someone who has been abusing substances or has been having a reaction to medication and they are seemingly not themself. In each of these scenarios, these folks likely need immediate help. Going to an ER or the nearest psychiatric facility may be the best option to immediately manage the crisis. If a person already has a psychiatrist or therapist, reaching out to them to let the know what is going on can be a tremendous help.

Generally, you can send mental health professionals information, but we cannot acknowledge it or send anything back to you without a consent to release information from the client. Exceptions to this rule may apply if there is an imminent threat to the life of the client or someone else.

As much as I encourage clients to take responsibility for their mental health and challenge when folks are enabling, there have been many times over the years that I have encouraged family members to write letters to their loved one's doctor or to call the office and leave a message to inform them if a crisis has developed or if there are significant pieces of information about symptoms necessary for the clinician to make an adequate diagnosis and appropriate treatment plan, and for their doctor to be able to prescribe the appropriate medications. These methods, when necessary can be absolute game changers in the trajectory of a client's mental health outcomes. 

When we have a release and family therapy or coordination of care is part of the treatment
As family therapists, especially when working with children it is very difficult to make changes with the child if the rest of the family is not on board and participating in the treatment. Some of the best results I have ever seen as trauma therapist have come immediately after sessions using Trauma Focused Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (TF-CBT) when parents are brought into the session to help process/witness the trauma of their child. Secrets are eliminated and parents are coached on how to be effective supporters in the present. The shame the child was experiencing dissipates and healing takes place in the family system.

Although interventions with loved one's have long been used in substance abuse recovery, there are mixed reviews of the efficacy of these attempts.


What about if it's a Britney situation and we think we need to become guardians or conservators in order to help our family member?

Sometimes a person is not well enough to take care of themself. They refuse treatment. They struggle with having the capacity to recognize the risk to themselves. In some cases, a person can apply for a conservatorship or guardianship with the courts. The court determines if this is appropriate.

Sometimes, when a family member is severely chronically ill and it no longer feels like there is another way to get them help to save their life, this step can be helpful.

However, it can also come with a large price. Family members have the burden of assuming medical and financial responsibility for their impaired family member, which is often a thankless, tiring, and exhausting job. The task and the subsequent blowback of resentment and fight for control from the client can result in major conflicts, and sometimes complete dissolution in the relationship between family members. As they say, no good deed goes unpunished. As we all saw with what happened with Britney Spears and her family over the conservatorship and when it was lifted, the process and outcome were complicated in their impact.

So, should you help a family member? Absolutely! But before you take those next steps, carefully consider your role, expectations of them, ask yourself whether it is possible they can do this for themself and how your involvement may help or hurt. Consider the impact that your helping may have on your own mental health.

Remember local resources like the 988 mental health crisis line as well as NAMI, AA, Al-Anon,  SAMHSA, and Psychology Today  are all excellent ways to help for yourself or to send the information to a loved one to encourage them to take steps for their own mental well being. If you think that maybe you are struggling with codependence with a family member, you can look into a CODA group for yourself.

Author
~Megan Garza, MA, LMFT